for myself I would go for the light ones, but girl, I know you and the black ones are just soo you!

black are beautiful, but i voted for the light ones too. almost every shoe, a shoe sales lady once told me, looks better in a color other than black - it brings out the details

thanks guys!!!! i need to check them with a dress this time and ill know for sure, no doubt the light ones are more stylish, its just that with a winter black tights... m not sure how would it be like

i can see how both would be useful, I fell for the blacks though, can imagine them with more outfits... :)

I would choose the lighter ones because it is closer to your skin tone so you can create one seamless line. However black tights and shoes achieve the same effect.

i have just bought some tiger of sweden shoes in the light colour they look amazing with black tights grey tights, woollen leggings i love them. nything to get awy from black, bit too officey x

Black usually goes with everything, but when it comes down to that warm, earthy color hue of brown.. I'm going to go with those!

Black just fades into the background,id definitley go for the cream ones.Stand out!